Finding Balance in the Volume Debate
When I first started training, I believed that doing more sets automatically meant more gains. Twelve sets per muscle group per session? Let’s go. But over time, I realized that as a natural lifter, more volume didn’t always equal better results. In fact, it often held me back.
Through years of experimenting, I’ve found that 1-2 high-quality working sets per exercise (sometimes 3, but rarely) gave me the best performance, recovery, and progress.
This approach isn’t a rule; it’s simply what works for me. Every lifter is different. The goal of this blog is to help you understand the science of effective volume and encourage you to test and discover what truly works for you.
Why Volume Matters and Why Less Can Be More
For natural athletes, training volume plays a huge role in growth, but only up to a point. Studies consistently show that muscle growth increases with volume, yet the returns diminish after a certain threshold.
Here's the reality:
- Your body has a limited recovery capacity as a natural lifter.
- Doing more sets doesn’t guarantee more muscle. It can just lead to fatigue and slower recovery.
- Fewer, harder, and more intentional sets often deliver better results when paired with smart progression and consistent effort.
In short, the quality of your sets matters more than the total number.
Why I Use 1-2 Working Sets (and Rarely 3)
My training shifted when I focused on performing fewer sets with higher intent. I stopped chasing pump volume and started chasing performance and progression.
Here’s why 1-2 working sets work for me:
- Better Focus: Each set demands full intensity and precision.
- Less Fatigue: I can train hard without digging myself into recovery debt.
- More Consistent Performance: My strength stays stable across weeks.
- Sustainable Long-Term: I recover faster, stay injury-free, and stay motivated.
That’s not to say three sets are wrong. Sometimes I’ll add a third for lagging areas or during a focused training block. Once again, it rarely happens, but most of the time, 1-2 working sets close to failure are enough to stimulate growth, without burning out.
How to Structure a Low-Volume, High-Intensity Training Approach
If you want to experiment with this method, keep things structured and intentional.
Here’s a simple framework:
- Exercises: Stick with key compound lifts and smart isolation work.
- Working Sets: Perform 1-2 intentional working sets per exercise near failure.
- Frequency: Train each muscle group 2-3 times per week. Potentially four; however, monitor your recovery.
- Progression: Track performance weekly. Aim to lift slightly heavier or perform more reps over time.
- Recovery: Prioritize sleep, nutrition, and rest days as much as training.
This approach isn’t “easy.” In fact, it demands more focus because you have fewer chances to make each set count. Nonetheless, the reward is measurable, consistent growth with less overall fatigue.
Testing What Works for You
Everyone’s response to volume is different. Some lifters thrive on higher sets; others do better with less. The only way to know is to test it.
Try this:
- Train your current volume for 4-6 weeks and track progress.
- Switch to 1–2 working sets per exercise for the next 4-6 weeks.
- Compare strength, energy, recovery, and body composition.
Whichever approach leaves you progressing steadily without overtraining or exhaustion is your sweet spot.
Faith, Discipline, and Stewardship in Training
As a faith-driven athlete, I see training not as punishment, but as stewardship, caring for the body God entrusted me with.
That means:
- Resting when needed isn’t laziness. It’s wisdom.
- Training with discipline reflects consistency, not obsession.
-
Pushing yourself honors the gift of strength and health.
Our bodies are temples, not machines. The goal isn’t to destroy them by chasing more sets; it’s to build them purposefully, sustainably, and with gratitude.
Simplicity Wins in the Long Run
- Effective volume isn’t about doing the most; it’s about doing what matters most.
- For many natural lifters, 1-2 hard-working sets per exercise might be all you need.
- Use science as guidance, not law.
- Test, track, and find what works for your physiology and recovery.
- And most importantly, stay consistent, stay humble, and keep your purpose rooted in something greater than the gym.
